Between the Posts: Newcastle’s Greatest Goalkeepers of All Time

Newcastle United has had its fair share of ups and downs, but one thing that has remained consistent over the decades is the club’s legacy of strong goalkeepers. The Best Newcastle Goalkeeper debate is one that always sparks passion among the Toon Army. This article ranks the top 10 best Newcastle goalkeepers of all time based on impact, longevity, fan love, and iconic moments. Let’s revisit the men who have stood tall between the posts at St. James’ Park. Don’t forget to visit Cheap football shirts in UK to get legendary jerseys with affordable prices.

Quick List of Best Newcastle Goalkeepers

1. Shay Given
2. Martin Dúbravka
3. Tim Krul
4. Nick Pope
5. Pavel Srníček
6. Karl Darlow
7. Fraser Forster
8. Shaka Hislop
9. Rob Elliot
10. Steve Harper

1. Shay Given

Shay Given is widely considered the Best Newcastle Goalkeeper in modern times. Signed from Blackburn in 1997, he quickly became a fan favorite for his incredible shot-stopping and composure. Despite playing behind shaky defenses, Given always stood out.

• Over 450 appearances for the club
• Named in PFA Team of the Year twice during his NUFC spell

Shay Given – The most consistent and admired keeper in Toon history (Image: The Guardian)

2. Martin Dúbravka

Since his debut against Manchester United in 2018, Dúbravka has been a model of consistency. A smart signing by Rafa Benítez, his sharp reflexes and calm demeanor have solidified his status as a top modern keeper.

• NUFC Player of the Season 2019–2020
• Saved crucial points in relegation battles and big matches

Martin Dubravka – A calm and reliable presence in the modern era (Image: Newcastle United)

See all list Cheap Newcastle United Football shirt and kits

3. Tim Krul

Krul made his first-team debut in Palermo and later became first choice. His best form came in 2011–12, helping NUFC to a 5th place finish. A powerful shot-stopper with strong instincts.

• Starred in 2011–2012 Premier League run
• Dutch international with a flair for big-game saves

Tim Krul – Heroic displays in Europe and the Premier League (Image: Sky Sports)

See all list Cheap Netherlands Football shirt and kits

4. Nick Pope

Joining from Burnley in 2022, Pope has been a revelation. His performances have made Newcastle one of the toughest defenses in the league. A true contender for Best Newcastle Goalkeeper in the coming years.

• Key figure in Newcastle’s return to European football
• Among the top Premier League shot-stoppers statistically

Nick Pope – The current wall of St. James’ Park (Image: BBC)

5. Pavel Srníček

Pav was a fan favorite during the Entertainers era under Kevin Keegan. Though not flawless, his passion and personality made him a Geordie icon. His commitment and charisma remain unforgettable.

• Over 150 appearances for the club
• Symbol of the mid-90s Keegan revolution

Pavel Srníček – Beloved cult hero of the Keegan era (Image: The Guardian)

6. Karl Darlow

Darlow proved his worth when called upon during Dúbravka’s injuries. Though a backup, he had standout performances that sparked debate over who should start.

• Man of the Match performances in 2020–2021
• Provided stability during key stretches

 

Karl Darlow – Stepped up during injury crises with strong form (Image: Shields Gazette)

7. Fraser Forster

Though he never made a senior appearance, Forster was a promising youth prospect. Newcastle’s failure to integrate him was a missed opportunity, as he later starred for Celtic and Southampton.

• Sold for just £2m; later worth £10m
• England international with strong European record

Fraser Forster – The one that got away (mage: FourFourTwo)

8. Shaka Hislop

Signed as competition for Srníček, Hislop brought physical presence and command in the air. While not as flashy, he was dependable when needed and a key figure in the mid-90s.

• Featured in the 1995–98 period of growth
• Brought balance to the squad’s goalkeeper depth

Shaka Hislop – Solid aerial command and Premier League experience (Image: NewcastleWorld)

9. Rob Elliot

Elliot never made headlines but was always ready when called. His professionalism and quiet resilience made him respected by fans and teammates alike.

• Long-serving backup keeper
• Trusted during promotion and relegation cycles

Rob Elliot – A steady hand during transition periods (Image: Kent Cricket)

10. Steve Harper

A true servant of the club, Harper spent two decades at NUFC, mostly as Given’s backup. He could have played more elsewhere, but his loyalty earned him legend status.

• Nearly 200 appearances despite fierce competition
• Testimonial in 2013 celebrated his dedication

Steve Harper – Loyalty personified with 20 years of service (Image: Newcastle United)

Conclusion

From the brilliance of Shay Given to the modern excellence of Nick Pope, each name on this Best Newcastle Goalkeeper list has played a unique role in the club’s legacy. Whether it was through loyalty, technical brilliance, or leadership, these ten shot-stoppers left their mark on the Toon Army. As Newcastle United looks ahead to future success, its tradition of elite goalkeepers remains intact.
Who’s your favorite NUFC goalkeeper of all time? Share your thoughts below.